maybe you can think of something the size of the 2600-vco to replace that would make you more happy, [...]
if you dont like the concept thats is fine, but i really wish yall would recommend specific swaps that keep the same footprint, because the size of the cases is also part of this concept. i wonder, though, if its just too abstract for yall, rather than being as flawed as yall claim. [...]
-- singular_soundi brought up neanderthals destroyed atlantis to make the point that every melodic voice doesnt need to sound like a xylophone, and that you can sometimes just work with nearly pure tones and end up with a desirable result. i dont have any plans to buy any eurorack. i am half thinking about investing into an 8 string practice electric guitar. i wanted to try to make some conceptual contributions to the community, more that exactly plan out my next purchases.
-- singular_sound
Okay this is funny. Why are you so defensive when you have no experience using modules and no plans to in the future? There's a serious disconnect with what you are asking for and what you expect. Posting real critique here (as you requested) is trying to make you happy, not the other way around. Anyone using a modular synth implicitly understands that imposing their own standards on someone else's instrument doesn't compute. That would be like getting pissed someone painted their personal guitar red instead of blue.
I don't think you want actual feedback, you want backpats and reassurance that your "novel concept" is worthy of praise. You've never even tuned an oscillator and think you can meaningfully contribute, well guess what: You're absolutely right. A tortured, misunderstood genius stands before us!